Workshop on GIS Tools Supporting Ecosystem Approaches to Management
held September 8-10, 2004


Workshop Summary

Workshop Presentations
Session 1: Wednesday, Sep. 8 – Morning
Applications of GIS Supporting Ecosystem Approaches to Management

This session demonstrated the state of the art on applying GIS to ecosystem management in marine fisheries or in allied fields. Specific attention was given to actual GIS tools, analyses, or procedures that are in use and the spatially related needs that have arisen through their application to real problems.

Introduction & Overview: The Challenges of Managing Marine Resources in 5 Dimensions

Steve Murawski, Project Manager, Ecosystem Pilot Projects

NOAA Fisheries, Office of Science and Technology

Biogeographic Assessments: The Integration of Ecology and GIS to Support Fishery Science and Management

Mark E. Monaco, NOS Biogeography Program Manager

National Centers for Coastal Ocean Science-Center for Coastal Monitoring & Assessments

Assessing Risk to the Essential Fish Habitat of West Coast Groundfish

Stephen Copps, Senior Policy Analyst

NMFS Northwest Region

Ecosystem-based Regional Marine Conservation Planning: The Nature Conservancy’s Approach to Ecoregional Assessments in the Marine Environment

Dan Dorfman, Senior Marine Conservation Planner

The Nature Conservancy - Global Marine Initiative

Session 2: Wednesday, Sep. 8 – Afternoon
Management Needs

Representatives from the Fishery Management Councils described interactions between fishery management plans and any limitations regarding, for example, EFH, trophic interactions, bycatch interactions etc. Each council pointed out the type of decision-making that is done with available information and what information is needed.

Management Needs of MAFMC Eco-GIS

Thomas Hoff

Mid-Atlantic Fisheries Management Council

GIS and EAF: Fishery management, current uses, considerations and data needs

Chad Demarest

New England Fishery Management Council

SAFMC Action Plan for Ecosystem-Based Management

SAFMC Habitat and Ecosystem website

Roger Pugliese, Senior Fishery Biologist and Gregg Waugh, Deputy Executive Director

South Atlantic Fishery Management Council

Session 3: Thursday, Sep. 9 – Morning
Data Availability and Data Gaps

The purpose of this session was to gauge the richness or sparseness of spatial data relating to the Atlantic Ocean and the Gulf of Mexico, and to learn from the experiences of our Pacific Coast colleagues. Each presenter provided a description of the spatial data for which their organization has primary responsibility for collecting and maintaining or for which they have special experience in utilizing for ecosystem-based management. Presenters also touched on notable gaps in spatial data that may hinder ecosystem-based approaches to management.

GIS Data for Research to Support Ecosystem-based Management - SEFSC

Steve Wong

NOAA Fisheries Southeast Fishery Science Center

The Need For Improved GIS Capabilities and an Overview of NEFSC Data on Fish Distribution, Hydrography and Seabed Habitat

Dr. Thomas Noji, Division Chief

Northeast Fisheries Science Center, Howard Marine Lab, Sandy Hook, NJ

GIS Activities within the National Ocean Service

Tony LaVoi, Acting Deputy Branch Chief

Coastal Information Services

Data Management at NCDDC

Sharon Mesick, Deputy Chief Scientist

NOAA National Coastal Data Development Center

Data Gaps in the Risk Assessment for West Coast Groundfish EFH

Waldo Wakefield, Habitat Conservation and Engineering Team Lead

NOAA Fisheries Northwest Fisheries Science Center

Session 4: Thursday, Sep. 9 – Afternoon
Science Needs

The Science Needs session surveyed the spatial analyses or tools that living marine resource scientists need to understand individual components of an ecosystem and how those components interact. Topics of discussion included delineation of ecosystem boundaries, incorporating spatial variation in stock assessments, characterizing species distribution and abundance, spatial variation in food webs, ecosystem services, and connectivity analysis.

Spatial Analysis Needs for Marine Ecosystem Management: Habitat Characterization, Spatio-temporal Models and Connectivity Analysis Frameworks

Pat Halpin, Director, Geospatial Analysis Program

Nicholas School of the Environment and Earth Sciences, Duke University

Beyond Maps: Using GIS to Identify Models and Evaluate Trade-offs in Fisheries Science

Paul Rago

NMFS Northeast Fisheries Science Center

Dolphinfish in the Western Atlantic—an Ecosystem Based Case Study

Kristen Kleisner

University of Miami, RSMAS